Redmond’s actions have gotten innocents killed and doomed countless people left alive on the surface.

By opening the doors to other survivors, Redmond exposes the citizens of the city to unknown threats.

If saving unknown civilians risked her family,Redmond has a vested interest in keeping the city hidden.

03217677_poster_w780.jpg

While Redmond’s arguments make a certain sense, she’s still a villain for acting on her fears.

Xavier’s emotions make his decision-making somewhat murky, even as he remains the central hero of the show.

Your Rating

Your comment has not been saved

Cast

There’s-A-Big-Harsh-Reality-About-Paradise’s-Villain-That-Has-To-Be-Addressed-After-Episode-5

Custom Image by Yeider Chacon

Sinatra / Samantha (Julianne Nicholson) threatens Cal not to reveal the truth in Paradise (2025) Season 1 Ep 5

Image via Hulu

Xavier (Sterling K. Brown) and Robinson (Krys Marshall) decide to unite to unmask Samantha/Sinatra in Paradise (2025) Season 1 Ep 5

Paradise (2025) Season 1 Ep 4-51

Image via Hulu

Headshot Of Sterling K. Brown In The Los Angeles premiere of ‘Atlas’

Headshot Of Julianne Nicholson

Paradise