The audience was excited about Carrie’s addition, as she was a competitor and winner in 2005.
However, this season has been scrutinized, and Carrie seems to be the only contributor held accountable.
Many believe the recent addition toAmerican Idolseason 23has been too lenient with her feedback.
As a previous contestant on the show, Carrie has admitted to struggling when rejecting performers.
However, she is settling into a new position, and a learning curve is expected.
Carries co-stars, Luke Bryan and Lionel Richie, have been in the same position.
Custom image by Cesar García
Carrie has been continuously improving, andshe can’t be blamed for low ratings or negative audience feedback.
The judges are looking for any reason to eliminate a contestant.
Every move, note, and aspect of the performance is meticulously examined.
Custom Image by Cesar Garcia
Carrie understandablywants to alleviate some of this pressure.
Carrie has gone out of her way to ensure that every contestant feels heard, welcomed, and appreciated.
She wants to give every contestant a fighting chance.
Custom Image by César García
You have the most important job.
Luke and Lionel have been letting down contestants gently throughout their seven-season stint on the show.
A Reddit thread from 2023 byGeorgeCasey9confronts the issue online.
Custom Image By César García
It would not be fair to point fingers at Carrie simply because she was the most recent cast member.
She has been an easy target.
Carries been an easy target due to her inexperience and celebrity status.
Popular figures will always attract more criticism than the average person.
Haters are more prone to criticizing celebrities due to jealousy, resentment, and distrust.
Their large audience and extensive reach mean more viewership from less supportive individuals.
Carrie can expect the scrutiny to linger, but it will die down with relevancy.
Discussion regardingCarries involvement is a hot topicnow, but with time, people will lose interest.
Carrie has signed a multi-year contract and plans on fulfilling it.
Carrie is simply paying her dues.
Insinuating that Luke and Lionel are flawless andonly Carrie can damage the shows reputationwouldnt be fair.
Outside of their arguably sugar-coated feedback,Luke and Lionel have been in their fair share of controversy.
Criticism ranged from confusion regarding the meaning of the word to anger with theinappropriatelanguage.
He attracted attention for his eliminations as well.
Some believe that Lionel was suggesting contestants find their own style, but his feedback was arguably vague.
Lukes biggest controversy surrounded a less-than-ideal confrontation with one contestant, Madai ChaKell.
After he offered criticism regarding hershaky voice,Madai mocked his southern accent in the lyrics.
Luke asked her why she emphasized the word heart and incorporated a southern twang.
Will Carrie Continue On The Show?
Carrie Is An Asset To The Competition
Carrie is an empathetic, talented, and knowledgeable performer.
Carrie has offered genuine, constructive feedback that has aided in the contestant’s development.
Carrie has the potential to beAmerican Idols favorite judge, but it will take time.
American Idolairs Sundays & Mondays at 8 p.m. on ABC.
